Manage and Track Blog Comments

Commented On Logo

By accident, I ran into a nice little script called Commented On. And after about a week’s worth of use, or so, I’ve decided that I simply must post about it!

Many blogs give the option to “subscribe to follow-up comments” when you’re posting a comment to their blog. This is a great option because it allows visitors to create a comment community, have discussions, and interact with the blogger themselves.

The problem with this strategy is that after awhile, you get sick of the eMail about new comments. Sometimes you’re done with the conversation, you have nothing further to say, or the comments just didn’t become interesting. For whatever reason, you’re done. Now to stop receiving comment updates you have to go back and unsubscribe from the post.

Let me be honest, rarely do I do it. I just keep deleting annoyed that I’m still getting the email. I’ve got little time to click, unsubscribe, and keep moving on. Moving away from my eMail by simply unsubscribing someplace distracts me from my focus and often times I lose train of thought.

It may sound crazy but remember, I’m the girl that keeps a schedule of my tasks and only allots a specific amount of time for each thing. I don’t want comments to be yet another thing that’s taking up my time.

The result, I no longer subscribe to comments. And then, after leaving my comment I attempt to remember where that thought provoking post was, hunt it down, and check out follow up comments.

With Commented On, I no longer have to do deal with the eMails or remembering where that great post was written.

Now, let’s get to why, after explaining my commenting problem, Commented On is great for me!

The function of Commented On is simple: bookmark to one place comments you have left on a blog. By keeping track of where I have left a comment, I’m able to go back on my own time to review more comments left on a post, continue the conversation, or simply just ignore the post. My choice.

Often times I don’t comment more than once on a post, but 9 times out of 10, I’m interested in reading how others reacted to the post. This means that I can do comment checking 100% on my own time.

Probably the best thing about Commented On is that it’s self-hosted. Yes, it’s a script that I have installed right here on I’m Blogging That. I’ve got a quick link to both the Java bookmarklet that caches my comments as well as the link to the comments themselves.

Because this script is on I’m Blogging That, I also confident that the only one that knows I’m following up on comments with different posts is me. And, I don’t have to actually comment on any posts just to keep track of the comments for that post. My information is secure, I can brand the design of Commented On to match I’m Blogging That and I choose when I receive information about new comments.

This has become one of my top 10 blogger must-haves. Comments are a great way to build traffic to your blog, especially if you’re going to leave thought worthy, insightful comments. I make attempts to do that every time I comment. And now, I have an easy way to catch up, on my own time.

Here’s the catch, in plain English. Self-Hosted means that you have to install it and you have to have a place to install it to. This means your own domain name and hosting. And you all know that I’m a huge advocate for owning your own domain and yet here’s another reason why.

Installation is incredibly simple! If you can manually (without Fantastico) install WordPress, you can install Commented On. Simple snap, done it just 5 minutes and you’re up and going.

So, what do you think? Will you be checking out Commented On and do you comment on enough blogs that having a comment bookmark application will help you keep track?

If you install or are thinking about install it, let me know what you think!

This website uses IntenseDebate comments, but they are not currently loaded because either your browser doesn't support JavaScript, or they didn't load fast enough.



9 Comments


  1. Louis LiemNo Gravatar
    at 8:58 am

    I’ve been using CoComment. All I need to do is installing a firefox plugin and sign up for an account and it tracks all my comments I left everywhere.
    I just need to login and have all the comment updates collected.

    Well, just sharing some information :)

    Thanks for the info!

  2. Mike NewNo Gravatar
    at 9:15 am

    This sounds like a great solution. I’m sick of having to delete those emails too.

  3. Damien RileyNo Gravatar
    at 10:13 am

    It sounds interesting. I amy come back to it though since I don’t (so far) have as much of the annoyance from the subscribing blog by blog.

  4. Damien RileyNo Gravatar
    at 10:36 am

    Hi Louis. You don’t find CoComment cumbersome? I had to re-enter my information twice on a lot of sites. Finally I disabled the FF plugin. How does it work exactly for you?

  5. KatyNo Gravatar
    at 10:28 am

    Louis » I’ve never heard of CoComment. I’ll have to investigate that one as well, just for resource information.

    Mike » Glad I’m not alone in the “don’t want to unsubscribe” boat. LOL

    Damien » I think my problem is that I comment on too many blogs and it gets tiring to keep up with those emails.

  6. aroengbinangNo Gravatar
    at 4:52 am

    I agree that subscribing to comments is sometimes quite annoying, and yes it would be interesting to read replies of our comments, and useful especially if the replies are answers of our questions. Have visited the site, but don’t really know how to do with the script…:)

  7. KatyNo Gravatar
    at 11:51 am

    Aroengbinang » I love keep track of comments and the following replies, it makes discussion quite easy.

    The Commented On script however, is something that needs to be installed with a hosting account. I noticed that you have a Blogger blog which would hinder you from installing this script where your blog is located. However, if you have a domain name and some private hosting elsewhere, it’s just a few simple clicks to get Commented On up and going.

  8. Louis LiemNo Gravatar
    at 8:41 am

    @Damien Riley

    It works fine with me. I experienced the problem you had, but only about once every 20 comments. So they’re very seldom happen to me.

  9. Susie QNo Gravatar
    at 10:38 am

    Yes, I also recently started using CoComment, seems pretty easy to use with nice user interface on their website- but good to know the options, anyone used both and able to compare?

Trackback(s)

Have Your Say!